Chinese Impact in the Western Balkans

Paper title:	*Chinese Impact in the Western Balkans: the Effect of the Belt and Road Initiative on the EU’s Normative Role*
DOI:	https://doi.org/10.4316/CC.2022.01.08
Published in:	Issue 1, (Vol. 28) / 2022
Publishing date:	2022-07-31
Pages:	171-202
Author(s):	Göktürk Tüysüzoğlu
Abstract:	China, which shows signs of trying to create an integrated historical bloc, also supports a process that will lead to the consolidation of authoritarian political patterns in parallel with its increasing investments and financial support in the frame of the Belt and Road Initiative. This study argues that China’s approach to the Western Balkans is an extension of the hegemony-building process. It brings the question of geopolitical concern regarding the enlargement strategy of the EU, which is seen as a normative power. Although this concern has been observed much more in the EU, it emphasises the reform process rather than enlargement. This situation, which could also be defined as a stability-democracy dilemma, not only undermines the normative power of the EU but also leads to the consolidation of illiberal regimes.
Keywords:	China, Western Balkans, EU, Hegemony, Illiberal Regimes, 17+1 Cooperation, Differentiated Integration.

References:	1. Althusser Louis, Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses (Notes Towards an Inves-tigation), in Althusser Louis, Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays, London, New Left Books, 1971, p. 166-176. 2. Arrighi Giovanni, The Three Hegemonies of Historical Capitalism, in Gill Stephen (Ed.), Gramsci, Historical Materialism and International Relations, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1993, p. 148-185. 3. Bami Xhorxhina, China Increasing its Footprint in Balkan Media, Study Concludes, “Balkan Insight”, 2020, https://balkaninsight.com/2020/12/09/china-increasing-its-footprint-in-balkan-media-study-concludes/. 4. Bastian Jens, Is China’s Win-Win Cooperation a Loss for Europe?, 2020, in reconasia. csis.org/chinas-win-win-cooperation-loss-europe/ 5. Belloni Roberto, The European Union Blowback? Euroscepticism and Its Consequences in the Western Balkans, “Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding”, Vol. 10, 2016, No. 4, p. 530-547. 6. Brattberg, Erik et al., Southeastern, Central and Eastern Europe: Vulnerabilities and Resilience in Four Countries, Washington, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, October 2021, 93 p. 7. Brautigam Deborah, A Critical Look at Chinese Debt-Trap Diplomacy: The Rise of a Meme, “Area Development and Policy”, Vol. 5, 2020, No. 1, p. 1-14. 8. Brînză, Andreea, The 17+1 Mechanism. Caught Between China and the United States, “China Quarterly of International Strategic Studies”, Vol. 5, 2019, No. 2, p. 213-231. 9. Can M. Ciwan, Chan Anson, Rethinking the Rise of China and Its Implications on Inter-national Order, “Chinese Journal of International Review”, Vol. 2, 2020, No. 1, 2050005, 21 p. 10. Casier Tom, The EU-Russia Strategic Partnership: Challenging the Normative Argu-ment, “Europe-Asia Studies”, Vol. 65, 2013, No. 7, p. 1377-1395. 11. Conley Heather A., et al., Avenues of Chinese Influence in the Western Balkans, in China’s “Hub-and-Spoke” Strategy in the Balkans. “CSIS Europe Program Report”, April, 2020, 22 p. 12. Cox Robert W., Gramsci, Hegemony and International Relations: An Essay in Method, “Millennium: Journal of International Studies”, Vol. 12, No. 2, 1983, p. 162-175. 13. Cox Robert W., Social Forces, States and World Orders: Beyond International Rela-tions Theory, “Millennium Journal of International Studies”, Vol. 10, 1981, No. 2, p. 126-155. 14. Cox Robert W., The International in Evolution, “Millennium Journal of International Studies”, Vol. 35, 2007, No. 3, p. 513-527. 15. Culpepper Pepper D., Structural Power and Political Science in the Post-Crisis Era, “Business and Politics”, Vol. 17, 2015, No. 3, p. 391-409. 16. Cvijic Srdjan, A Ship Without a Rudder? The EU Strategy in the Western Balkans, in IEMed Mediterranean Yearbook 2020, Barcelona, European Institute of the Mediterranean (IEMed), 2021, p. 205-208. 17. Emerson Michael, Scenarios for a Wider Europe, “CEPS Policy Insights”, No. 2, 2019, 19 p. 18. Fisher-Onar Nora, Nicolaidis Kalypso, The Decentring Agenda: Europe as a Post-Co-lonial Power, “Cooperation and Conflict”, Vol. 48, 2013, No. 2, p. 283-303. 19. Forsberg Tuomas, Normative Power Europe. Once Again: A Conceptual Analysis of an Ideal Type, “Journal of Common Market Studies”, Vol. 49, 2011, No. 6, p. 1183-1204. 20. Gafuri Adea, Müftüler-Bac Meltem, Caught Between Stability and Democracy in the Western Balkans: A Comparative Analysis of Paths of Accession to the European Union, “East European Politics”, Vol. 37, 2021, No. 2, p. 267-291. 21. Gill Stephen, Law David, Global Economy and Structural Power of Capital, “Interna-tional Studies Quarterly”, Vol. 33, 1989, No. 4, p. 475-499. 22. Gill Stephen, Gramsci and Global Politics: Towards a Post-Hegemonic Research Agen-da, in Gill Stephen (Ed.), Gramsci, Historical Materialism and International Relations, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1993, p. 1-20. 23. Gill, Stephen, Hegemony, Consensus and Trilateralism, “Review of International Stud-ies”, Vol. 12, 1986, No. 3, p. 205-221. 24. Hoare Quentin, Nowell Smith Geoffrey (Eds.), Selections from the Prison Notebooks of Antonio Gramsci, New York, International Publishers, 1978. 25. Human Rights Watch Report, “Break Their Lineage, Break Their Roots”. China’s Crimes against Humanity Targeting Uyghurs and Other Turkic Muslims, Mills Legal Clinic, 2021, https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/19/break-their-lineage-break-their-roots/ chinas-crimes-against-humanity-targeting. 26. Hyde-Price Adrian, A Tragic Actor? A Realist Perspective on Ethical Power Europe, “International Affairs”, Vol. 84, 2008, No. 1, p. 29-44. 27. Ilic Vujo, Serbia’s Vucic Takes an Illiberal Turn, in “Balkan Insight”, 2021, https://balkaninsight.com/2021/10/11/serbias-vucic-takes-an-illiberal-turn/ 28. Keukeleire Stephan, The European Union as a Diplomatic Actor: Internal, Traditional and Structural Diplomacy, “Diplomacy and Statecraft”, Vol. 14, 2003, No. 3, p. 31-56. 29. Kmezic Marko, Rule of Law and Democracy in the Western Balkans: Addressing the Gap Between Policies and Practice, “Southeast European and Black Sea Studies”, Vol. 20, 2020, No. 1, p. 183-198. 30. Koharovic Nebojsa, Croatia, China Hitting the Fast Lane of Cooperation, 2019, http://www.chinatoday.com.cn/ctenglish/2018/ii/201904/t20190429_800166589.html 31. Laclau Ernesto, Mouffe Chantal, Hegemony and Socialist Strategy, Towards a Radical Democratic Politics, London – New York, Verso, 2001, 198 p. 32. Larsen Henrik, NATO in an Illiberal World, “The RUSI Journal”, Vol. 166, 2021, No. 3, p. 84-92. 33. Maglaras Vasilis, Consent and Submission: Aspects of Gramsci’s Theory of the Politi-cal and Civil Society, “SAGE Open”, January-March Issue, 2013, p. 1-8. 34. Manners Ian, Normative Power Europe: A Contradiction in Terms?, “Journal of Com-mon Market Studies”, Vol. 40, 2002, No. 2, p. 235-258. 35. Mardell Jacob, Beijing Fills Gaps Left by Brussels in the Western Balkans, “MERICS”, 2021, https://merics.org/en/short-analysis/beijing-fills-gaps-left-brussels-western-balkan 36. Markovic Khaze Nina, Wang Xiven, Is China’s Rising Influence in the Western Balkans a Threat to European Integration?, “Journal of Contemporary European Studies”, Vol. 29, 2021, No. 2, p. 234-250. 37. Mearsheimer J. John, The Gathering Storm: China’s Challenge to US Power in Asia, “The Chinese Journal of International Politics”, Vol. 3, 2010, No. 4, p. 381-396. 38. Moolakkattu S. John, Robert W. Cox and Critical Theory of International Relations, “International Studies”, Vol. 46, 2009, No. 4, p. 439-456. 39. Neshikj Ilina, Spasovska Biljana, Filling Democracy Gaps in the Western Balkans, 2020, https://carnegieeurope.eu/2020/12/07/filling-democracy-s-gaps-in-western-balkans-pub-83147 40. Okić Tijana, The Debt of Integration: Montenegro’s Chinese Loan and the Traps of Europe, 2021, https://www.cadtm.org/The-debt-of-integration-Montenegro-s-Chinese-loan-and-the-traps-of-Europe 41. Okur Mehmet Akif, Gramsci, Cox ve Hegemonya: Yerelden Küresele, İktidarın Sosyo-lojisi Üzerine [Gramsci, Cox and Hegemony: From the Local to the Global, On the Sociology of Power], “Uluslararası İlişkiler”, Vol. 12, 2015, No. 46, p. 131-151. 42. Ferruccio Pastore (Ed.), Beyond the Migration and Asylum Crisis. Options and lessons for Europe, Roma, Aspen Institute Italia, 2017, 121 p. 43. Pastore Ferruccio, From Source to Corridor: Changing Geopolitical Narratives About Migration and EU-Western Balkans Relations, “Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies”, Vol. 21, 2019, No. 1, p. 11-26. 44. Pavlicevic Dragan, Structural Power and China-EU-Western Balkans Triangular Rela-tions, “Asia-Europe Journal”, Vol. 17, 2019, No. 4, p. 453-468. 45. Petrovic Milenko, Tzifakis Nikolaos, A Geopolitical Turn to EU Enlargement, or An-other Postponement?, “Journal of Contemporary European Studies”, Vol. 29, 2021, No. 2, p. 157-168. 46. Petrovic Milenko, Wilson Garth, Bilateral Relations in the Western Balkans as a Challenge For EU Accession, “Journal of Contemporary European Studies”, Vol. 29, 2021, No. 2, p. 201-218. 47. Prelec Tena, Our Brothers, Our Saviours: The Importance of Chinese Investment for the Serbian Government’s Narrative of Economic Rebound. Policy paper, Prague Security Studies Institute, Prague, 2020, 18 p. 48. Przychodniak Marcin, The Importance of the Western Balkans in China’s Foreign Pol-icy, “PISM Bulletin”, No. 123 (1553), 2020, p. 1-2. 49. Rankovic Rade, China Grows Balkan Investments by Asking Less Than EU, Say Ex-perts, 2021, https://www.voanews.com/a/china-grows-balkan-investments-by-asking-less-than-eu-say-experts-/6349558.html 50. Robinson I. William, Globalization, World System and Democracy Promotion in US Foreign Policy, “Theory and Society”, 1996, No. 25, p. 615-665. 51. Rogers Samuel, Illiberal Capitalist Development: Chinese State-Owned Capital Invest-ment in Serbia, “Contemporary Politics”, Vol. 28, 2022, No. 3, p. 347-364. 52. Rrustemi Arlinda, et al., Geopolitical Influences of External Powers in the Western Balkans, “Hague Centre for Strategic Studies”, 2021, 195 p. 53. Schechter Darrow, The Historical Bloc: Toward a Typology of Weak States and Con-temporary Legitimation Crises, in McNally Mark (Ed.), Antonio Gramsci: Critical Explorations in Contemporary Political Thought, London, Palgrave Macmillan, 2015, p. 179-194. 54. Shopov Vladimir, Decade of Patience: How China Became a Power in the Western Balkans, “ECFR Policy Brief”, No. 371, 2021, 26 p. 55. Shopov Vladimir, Getting on the Radar: China’s Rising Media Presence in South East Europe, “Konrad Adenauer Stiftung Media Programme South East Europe”, 2020, 35 p. 56. Sjursen Helene, The EU as a Normative Power: How Can This Be?, “Journal of Europe-an Public Policy”, Vol. 13, 2006, No. 2, p. 235-251. 57. Smith Nicholas Ross, Markovic Khaze Nina, Kovacevic Maja, The EU’s Stability-De-mocracy Dilemma in the Context of the Problematic Accession of the Western Balkan States, “Journal of Contemporary European Studies”, Vol. 29, 2021, No. 2, p. 169-183. 58. Stevic Ljiljana, The Evolution of Chinese Cultural Diplomacy and Its Impact on the BiH Perception of the Belt and Road Initiative and China-CEE Cooperation, “China CEE Institute Working Paper”, No. 22, 2020, 23 p. 59. Vladisavljev Stefan, Surveying China’s Digital Silk Road in the Western Balkans, “War on the Rocks Commentary”, 2021, https://warontherocks.com/2021/08/surveying-chinas-digital-silk-road-in-the-western-balkans/ 60. Wan Ming, The AIIB Versus the World Bank and the ADB, in Wan Ming, The Asian In-frastructure Investment Bank: The Construction of Power and the Struggle for the East Asian International Order, New York, Palgrave Macmillan, 2016, p. 58-91. 61. Warleigh-Lack Alex, Differentiated Integration in the European Union: Towards a Comparative Regionalism Perspective, “Journal of European Public Policy”, Vol. 22, 2015, No. 6, p. 871-887. 62. Webb Jonathan, The Refugee Crisis and Its Transformative Impact on EU-Western Balkans Relations, “Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies”, Vol. 48, 2020, No. 6, p. 1363-1380. 63. Wunsch Natasha, EU Enlargement and Civil Society in the Western Balkans. From Mobilisation to Empowerment, Zurich, Palgrave Macmillan, 2018, 171 p. 64. Zweers Wouter et al., China and the EU in Western Balkans: Different Strings At-tached, “Clingendael Institute Report”, 2020, 58 p.